Resident makes NYT point at county commission

Elissa Malcohn makes a point during Tuesday's county commission meeting regarding the New York Times digital-subscription issue. 

Citrus County is in the national spotlight due to commissioners blocking the library system from spending about $2,700 a year over three years for a digital subscription to the New York Times that could be accessed free by any of the county’s 70,000 library card holders.

Based on some of the comments we’ve seen — and there have been plenty — it seems like a good time to bring everyone up to speed on what happened, what didn’t and where it goes from here:

Q: Why are county commissioners opposed to having the New York Times in the libraries? Don’t they realize the Times is all the news that’s fit to print?

A: Commissioners never said they don’t want the Times in the libraries. The print edition is available in the libraries now and this issue is unrelated.

Q: So what’s the problem?

A: In late October, the board had a request from library director Eric head to sign a three-year contract with the New York Times for a digital subscription that can be shared by all library card holders. Led by Commissioner Scott Carnahan, who labeled the Times as “fake news,” the commission declined the request.

Q: What was the vote?

A: There actually was no vote. Commissioner Brian Coleman made a motion to approve the request and Carnahan seconded the motion. After brief discussion, the motion was withdrawn and commissioners went on with their agenda.

Q: Why should my taxes pay for a digital subscription when the print edition is now available in the libraries?

A: That was Commissioner Ron Kitchen Jr.’s initial argument and other commissioners have mentioned that as well.

Q: And … ?

A: Well, one argument raised is that not everyone has access to the library and not every library has the same print subscription. Coastal Region in Crystal River and the Homosassa libraries carry only the Sunday Times. The county pays about $3,000 a year for the print subscription.

Q: Why was board approval necessary for a newspaper subscription?

A: Anything that requires the board chairman’s signature on a contract goes to the county commission for approval.

Q: Wasn’t this already in the library’s budget?

A: The contract still needs board approval even if it’s budgeted.

Q: I’d rather see that $2,700 be used for something else, like paving roads. Can’t we do that instead?

A: While the library is tax-supported, it’s with a special library property tax. The library tax is 0.3217 mills — about $32 for the average homeowner. Money raised for the library taxing district cannot be used for anything but libraries.

Q: I’ve read online comments and tweets that the county commission cancelled the Times’ subscription. Is that true?

A: No. The print subscription still exists and the county never had a digital subscription to the Times.

Q: Surely someone, not the taxpayers, can step up and help.

A: They are! Since the Washington Post picked up the story Tuesday and numerous other national media followed, 11 gofundme.com pages were set up to raise money for the subscriptions. In all, nearly $9,000 was raised — enough to pay for the three-year subscription. Plus, the Chronicle received several emails from individuals offering to help pay, and the Society of Professional Journalists Florida chapter has also offered to help.

Q: Where do I send my check?

A: Not so fast. The library system doesn’t want to accept any private donations for a subscription that it technically does not have. Even if private funds are raised, it still needs board approval.

Q: Where does it stand now?

A: Commissioner Coleman has it scheduled for the Tuesday, Nov. 19 board agenda and is recommending the county give up the print New York Times subscription for the digital one. The commission meeting starts at 1 p.m. at the courthouse in Inverness.

Contact Chronicle reporter Mike Wright at 352-563-3228 or mwright@chronicleonline.com.

(11) comments

Phunkasaurus Wrex

Does anyone else think Mayor Meek opening a real estate brokerage constitutes a conflict of interest? Asking for a friend.

Jlbltd

The NY Times is recognized worldwide as one of the best papers of national and international news. Not everyone can go to a library to read the news outside the Citrus area. We can’t have this area have such limited and parochial views as being espoused by some. Current viewing of national and world happenings is important education for all. Proposed private donations take away any taxpayer burden statements. Perhaps if it was more readily available elected officials would not make such outrageous statements as The NY Times being “fake news”. JL Bartells

CRabe

Q: Why are county commissioners opposed to having the New York Times in the libraries? Don’t they realize the Times is all the news that’s fit to print?

A: Commissioners never said they don’t want the Times in the libraries. The print edition is available in the libraries now and this issue is unrelated.

From your own article:

“I don’t want the New York Times in this county,” Carnahan said then.

t

TimothyGiellis

Snowbird here. I love Citrus County just the way it is. I hope it never changes. Hats off to the BOCC for perpetuating that "Old Florida" image which is so unattractive to so many. Unattractive not only to people but corporations,and organizations as well. Stay stuck Critus.....I love ya just the way you are!!!

Michael9DuT

We pay the NYT "approximately" $3,000.00 a year for their printed paper. If you want to read the NYT, that is your business and feel free to go to the library and read. Paying them an additional $2,700.00 for a "digital version" is ridiculous. If someone in Citrus wants the digital version then they can subscribe!!! End of story.

equinn

Once approved, can we pay for digital subscription and cancel paper version?

LARRYG

What part of NO don't you understand, the N or the O. We don't need any more of anything from new york times.

CitrusCo Citizen

What part of $7000 raised nationwide by private donations don't you understand? We don't need to have our reading preferences dictated by your dumb Commissioners' politics, we'll get our digital subscription anyway. 7 grand will pay for 3 years, and thank you, America.

crizor

What PART of they can't use public funds to pay for it don't YOU understand? Jeesh.

Ssabmud

That korny line of what part of NO...may have worked on your little kids and may work on Russian citizens, but it really slides right off the backs of hard working Americans who have worked and fought hard for their rights. Another thing, Smith needs to prove that all of those “vicious” comments sent to commissioners were all from Democrats. It appears that he is trying to put his Trump worshipping on all Republicans. I don't buy that all Republicans feel that way about Trump and America and their hard earned rights.

rmcconnell

Can’t the politics be put aside for now. If the digital version works better than the paper, get it. Pick one, not both. If you like the Times, read it. If you don’t, don’t. Problem solved!

Welcome to the discussion.

Keep it Clean. Please avoid obscene, vulgar, lewd, racist or sexually-oriented language.
PLEASE TURN OFF YOUR CAPS LOCK.
Don't Threaten. Threats of harming another person will not be tolerated.
Be Truthful. Don't knowingly lie about anyone or anything.
Be Nice. No racism, sexism or any sort of -ism that is degrading to another person.
Be Proactive. Use the 'Report' link on each comment to let us know of abusive posts.
Share with Us. We'd love to hear eyewitness accounts, the history behind an article.