Hampton Family Trust Property

On Thursday, the Crystal River Planning Commission voted 4-3 to deny a developer's variance requests to build a five-story boutique hotel on the vacant waterfront lot, pictured above, owned by the Mike Hampton Family Trust that's controlled by the former major league pitcher.

Editor's Note: This story was updated to show that Crystal River staff did not recommend the approval of the development's latest variance requests.

With a narrow vote during a tense hearing, Crystal River’s building board denied a developer’s specialized requests for their proposed high-rise hotel on an empty waterfront lot along the city’s main thoroughfare.

Citizen members of the city’s planning commission voted 4-3 at its Thursday evening meeting to reject Bent Twig, LLC’s application for five variances to build a 55-unit, five-story boutique hotel and 2,450-square-foot, ground-floor restaurant on 300 S. U.S. 19.

Bent Twig was asking commissioners to: reduce the required landscape buffer around its land; decrease the waterfront setback to build a pool 10 feet from shore; and lower the number of minimum parking spots from 94 to 75, and make the spaces smaller.

Commission Chairman Robert Froehling, who led the vote to oppose the variances, said the building’s size and design, and ratio of rooms to parking, doesn’t fit the openness, accessibility and style the city wants when people explore its downtown along King’s Bay.

“It’s a little bit much,” he said. “That’s a lot of structure and not a lot of parking.”

Steve Spencer, Bent Twig partner and president of Spencer and Associates Architecture, and his project engineer, Housh Ghovaee, said the variance requests were made under the recommendations of the city’s planning and development director, Brian Herrmann.

“We met the goals and objectives of the city through Brian’s vision,” said Ghovaee, CEO of Northside Engineering, Inc. in Clearwater.

Prime property will likely see new owner

Hampton Family Trust, LLC, a trust controlled by former major league pitcher Mike Hampton, owns the 1.35-acre property in question. 

Partners of Bent Twig agreed with the Hampton trust to finalize a development plan for the property in exchange for its purchase, according to Herrmann.

Spencer said he’s trying to have Wyndham manage the condominium hotel, and told commissioners the hospitality company won’t agree to having less than 55 units and other construction conditions.

Bent Twig is also planning to construct a single-story retail building and additional parking on a 0.40-acre triangle plot across from Northwest Sixth Street.

Spencer told commissioners he’s tried to cooperate with Herrmann and city staff since early October over a site plan that included the variances and a walkway that split the lot, allowing people to walk freely between Northwest Sixth Street and the city’s future Riverwalk.

Spencer said that design was the city’s compromise for allowing a smaller parking lot, and he’s now considering removing the pathway from plans altogether if city staff won’t work with him.

“We’re not obligated to have access to the Riverwalk,” he said. “I just don’t understand why we’re having this difficulty … we’re losing parking spaces and creating more green space, and now, we’re getting penalized for not having enough parking.”

Loder has heart set on Hampton property

Spencer said he’s tired of the back-and-forth, and could still follow through on his project without asking for variances.

He said his proposed site plan and structure — except for the pool setback — conform to city code when it comes to the building’s height limit of 55 feet and its surface ratio on the lot.

“We can meet code without going in front of you,” Spencer told commissioners, “but we’re trying to do something to help the city.”

Herrmann implored commissioners in his staff presentation Thursday to consider how the variances would entice pedestrians from the neighboring city Riverwalk and walkways, and incorporate more landscaping into the lot, rather than carpet it with unappealing asphalt.

“If we just put up a building … and there’s nothing redeeming to pedestrians, we’re creating the same old style,” Herrmann said about the reasoning behind city codes. “The intent … gives deference to pedestrians, not vehicles.”

In this case, city staff did not recommend the approval of the variances, according to Herrmann's report.

Herrmann told commissioners he was awaiting Bent Twig’s latest design and elevation plans since Oct. 24, when the commission tabled the first variance hearing.

Pinellas developer John Loder Sr. dies at 51 before getting chance to build up Crystal River

Until he gets those documents, Herrmann said he can’t tell if the hotel project meets code, but said the hotel’s height should be acceptable.

Referring to recent phone calls and emails with Herrmann updating him of their project, Spencer and Ghovaee said they were surprised to hear Herrmann say he had yet to get their schematics.

They also expected a smooth vote Thursday in favor of their variances because they believed that’s what the city wanted.

“I had no concerns because I felt that we provided something that (Herrmann) really likes,” Ghovaee said.

Froehling asked Spencer before his testimony Thursday to apologize to Herrmann for being “rude” when discussing the project in a phone conversation.

“You’re bullying our director, you’re bullying this commission … and you’re bullying the city of Crystal River,” he said.

John Loder's partners to keep late Pinellas County developer's dreams alive

Spencer said he won’t apologize to somebody who tells him one thing but means another.

“(Herrmann) has been talking out of both sides of his mouth,” he said. “Everybody has two sides of the story, and I’m not apologizing to anyone or anybody else.”

Ghovaee said he will continue working with Herrmann to make the project happen.

“This project is a catalyst to this city, and a lot of investors are looking to come to this city and develop,” he told commissioners. “This project fits your town.”

Contact Chronicle reporter Buster Thompson at 352-564-2916 or bthompson@chronicleonline.com.

(7) comments

RBrazeal

I applaud the Planning Board for taking the long view. A boutique hotel would be a wonderful addition to Crystal River but this plan had too many serious flaws.

CRabe

Too bad, probably would have been a great thing. Here comes another gas station.

DParker

The lot is too small for the developers plan. It's not the cities job to change the rules to fit his plan.There are parking problems already and the developer wants fewer required spaces that will be smaller. where will the guests park their cars & boats ?

HANSW

citrus county needs more manufacturing which pay a decent wage than a 5 story hotel which will pay most of their employees only minimum waged.The hotel will stick up like a sore thumb in Chrystal River

AlvinJohnson

Citrus County does not only belong to the retiries or those that want zero development. Our area needs more than Dunkin Dounts and gas stations to provide people jobs and revenue. This was a step towards a stronger economy for Citrus County.

ROGERP

Amen!

Miuke Nelson

A Wyndham hotel isn't that much different from from Dunkin of a gas station when it comes to non-executive pay. PayScale.com shows the average starting hourly wage to be $8 per hour for desk clerks to $10 per hour for a General Manager.

Dunkin' is the same range and WAWA is actually a little higher (for managers).

Welcome to the discussion.

Keep it Clean. Please avoid obscene, vulgar, lewd, racist or sexually-oriented language.
PLEASE TURN OFF YOUR CAPS LOCK.
Don't Threaten. Threats of harming another person will not be tolerated.
Be Truthful. Don't knowingly lie about anyone or anything.
Be Nice. No racism, sexism or any sort of -ism that is degrading to another person.
Be Proactive. Use the 'Report' link on each comment to let us know of abusive posts.
Share with Us. We'd love to hear eyewitness accounts, the history behind an article.