John William Campbell resentencing

John William Campbell walks to his seat Monday, June 7, inside Circuit Court Judge Richard "Ric" Howard's courtroom. Campbell, who was previously on death row, is being resentenced by Judge Howard for murdering his father, John Henry “Jack” Campbell, in August 2010.

Lawyers wrapped up their arguments for a judge to decide the revised fate of John William Campbell for the August 2010 first-degree murder of his father inside their Inverness home.

Prosecutors and public defenders presented closing statements to Circuit Court Judge Richard “Ric” Howard, Friday, June 11, ending Campbell’s weeklong resentencing hearing.

After reviewing evidence attorneys showed him since Monday and during Campbell’s trial from January 2013, Howard will order the 47-year-old on June 23 to either serve life in prison or return to death row.

John William Campbell resentence secondary

Circuit Court Judge Richard "Ric" Howard addresses Assistant State Attorney Pete Magrino Monday, June 7, as a resentencing hearing for John William Campbell begins.

Campbell waived his right for a jury to preside over his resentencing, and opted Friday not to testify himself.

For murdering 68-year-old John Henry “Jack” Campbell with a hatchet, Howard originally sentenced Campbell to death by lethal injection in March 2013. 

However, Campbell became due for a new punishment in 2017 after the U.S. and Florida supreme courts ruled it unconstitutional because Campbell’s 12 jurors weren’t unanimous (8-4) in recommending the sentence to Howard.

Campbell gets death (File)

Citrus County Circuit Court Judge Richard “Ric” Howard reads convicted murderer John Campbell’s sentencing order at a March 2013 hearing while holding the murder weapon Campbell used to attack and kill his father in August 2010. Campbell received the death penalty for bludgeoning his father with the hatchet, killing him in his Inverness home.

Campbell has also been serving a 95-year prison term for a string of robberies in Inverness he committed leading up to his father’s murder on Aug. 10, and for his Aug. 11 pursuit with police that ended with him crashing into a Citrus County Sheriff’s Office cruiser, missing a deputy.

Throughout Campbell’s resentencing, his team of legal defenders called on doctors to testify on Campbell’s fetal-alcohol syndrome, brain damage, congenital defects, hostile upbringing, and post-traumatic stress.

Resentencing hearing starts for man who murdered his father

Those expert witnesses opined those factors culminated into “an extreme mental and emotional disturbance” that influenced Campbell to murder his father, but lessened his immoral intent and ability to appreciate the criminality.

John Campbell May 2021

John William Campbell, pictured in May 2021

In her closing statements, which included a timeline of Campbell’s life, Assistant Public Defender Jessica Roberts cited troves of records and outlined the opinions of seven defense witnesses to help show Howard Campbell doesn’t deserve death.

Bulk of defense witnesses testify in John Campbell's resentencing for father's 2010 murder

“The mitigation greatly outweighs the aggravation,” she said. “Mr. Campbell is not among the worst of the worst, he’s among the most damaged.”

Roberts said Campbell tried to recover from his childhood abuses, but his depression dragged him back into despair, which resulted in numerous suicide attempts and psychiatric treatments.

“Poisoned in the womb, predestined to fail, plunged into a lifetime of disfunction — that is the life of John William Campbell…” she said. “He was born into a life of so many deficits, he never had a shot.”

Prosecutors put on rebuttal in Campbell's resentencing for father's murder

Assistant State Attorney Pete Magrino said in his closing Campbell’s murder was “cold, calculated and premeditated,” and that Campbell was levelheaded before, during and after it.

“The bottom line is simple,” the prosecutor said before pointing at Campbell in the courtroom. “That defendant has earned ... to stay on death row until the governor of this state signs his death warrant.”

Prosecution sets pace (File)

Assistant State Attorney Pete Magrino displays a photograph of homicide victim John H. Campbell, to jurors during John William Campbell's trial in January 2013.

Magrino showed Howard photos of Jack Campbell from when he was alive and when his bludgeoned body was found in a chair inside his home off of East Nugget Lane, where his son moved to in December 2009 from Texas, where Campbell grew up since he was 8.

To help prove the “horrendous” nature of Campbell’s actions, Magrino played video footage of Campbell’s interview with forensic psychiatrist Dr. Emily Lazarou from February 2020.

Lazarou testified Thursday to diagnosing Campbell with anti-social personality disorder, substance-use disorder, mood disorder and borderline personality disorder. She also said Campbell meets the criteria for psychopathy.

Roberts said Lazarou’s testimony should be excluded because of her inconsistent diagnoses and prescriptions for Campbell since she was his psychiatrist in 2010 and 2011 after his arrest.

Roberts added Lazarou also shouldn’t be testifying against her former patient.

Campbell's resentencing continues with testimony of his psychologists

Campbell told Lazarou he struck his father’s head twice with a hammer-hatchet he got from a carport.

He then answered a phone call from the sheriff’s office asking about his father’s wellbeing. Campbell was able to divert authorities by pretending to be his father.

After Campbell hung up the phone, he struck his father with the hatchet a third time before the sheriff’s office called again. Campbell, again impersonating his father, told the agency to call back in the morning because “he was old and tired.”

“The defendant said,” Magrino said, reciting an interview Campbell’s gave with detectives, “‘I wanted to put him to death for a few days…I’ve been meditating on it and I didn’t know how ... but I figured I was going to do it, and I did it.’”

Campbell rifled through his father’s wallet, stole his car, drove to a local Walmart and bought gift cards he exchanged for crack cocaine. Campbell then drove to a St. Petersburg beach before he travelled back north via U.S. 19.

Hernando and Citrus county deputies pursued Campbell in a high-speed chase, which ended at the Hernando-Citrus border with Campbell crashing into a patrol car.

Magrino also referred Howard to Campbell’s “violent” felony convictions from the late ‘90s out of Texas, where he robbed a bank while armed, and broke into his ex-sister-in-law’s house, hid in her closet and ambushed her with a hammer.

‘To pursue or not to pursue’

In a file photo from Aug. 11, 2010, deputies pursued John Campbell, of Inverness, in a high-speed chase on U.S.19 near the Hernando County line that ended up in a collision that sent Campbell and a Citrus County Sheriff’s deputy to the hospital after he was struck with debris from the accident. Authorities said Campbell intentionally rammed into the police car.

Roberts argued Campbell committed those offenses, including the murder, soon after he experienced a severe depressive episode or tried to take his life, including the crash into the sheriff's cruiser.

“(Campbell) was quoted as saying,” Roberts said, “‘I don’t have the will to live, but I don’t the courage to kill myself.’”

Contact Chronicle reporter Buster Thompson at 352-564-2916,  bthompson@chronicleonline.com or visit tinyurl.com/yxn2ahso to see more of his stories.

Load comments

Thank you for reading!

Please purchase a subscription to read our premium content. If you have a subscription, please log in or sign up for an account on our website to continue.